In the long-term care world, Saturday Night Live’s “Sisters” sketch about adult children caregivers is getting lots of buzz. If you didn’t see it, the premise was simple: Feckless sons dumping the care of their aging parents on to their sisters.

Amusing, in a depressing sort of way. Yet it did an extremely important service by raising attention to caregiving. After all, being the subject of an SNL sketch will do vastly more to elevate the issue than government’s perfunctory annual designation of Caregiver Month.

But sadly, SNL largely missed the real truths of family caregiving.

It Isn’t About Gender

The problem is not sons ditching their responsibilities. In fact, millions of sons do take on this role. Rather it is that in many families, one person will bear most of the burden, regardless of gender. And, critically, their family will be doing this largely on its own, with little or no outside help.

If you are poor, you have Medicaid. If you are rich, you can buy help. But if you are middle-income, perhaps with a full-time job and lots of other financial and personal responsibilities, caregiving is really, really hard. Whether you are a son, a daughter, a spouse, a grandchild, or a neighbor. It is hard.

Family caregivers are the bedrock of the nation’s long-term care system. They provide about 80% of home-based care, usually without any paid assistance.

However, only about one-third of family caregivers are daughters. In reality, about  40% are men. They do different tasks than women. They may approach caregiving very differently. But they are in the picture much more often than conventional wisdom—or SNL– would have us believe.

Trust me. I know. I was a caregiver for both of my parents.

What Caregiving Really Is Like

The sketch is right that woman bear most of the burden. They are more likely to provide the most personal care, such as bathing a parent or helping parents to and from the bathroom. Some are more likely to handle finances, driving, managing medications, and the like.

And women who leave their jobs to care for a loved one are likely to suffer significant financial declines, from lost wages to shrunken 401(k)s and fewer Social Security benefits.

Are there SNL-like sons who hand over caregiving to their sisters because they don’t want to be bothered? Or because they are scared? For sure. Do some brothers automatically assume caregiving is a woman’s role, and thus leave it to female relatives? Yup. I’ve seen it.

But there also are sons who dive into caregiving with both feet, doing tasks they never would have imagined. There are sisters who can’t or won’t do the work. There even are daughters who refuse to allow their brothers any caregiving role. That’s the real world.

In our highly mobile society, caregiving often comes down to location rather than gender. If mom lives in Chicago, a mile from one daughter, while another daughter is in Atlanta, who do you think is most likely to end up as the primary caregiver?

Or it may be about other obligations. If Jane has a full-time job and three kids while brother Joe has grown kids and works from home, most of the care giving may fall to Joe. And, yes, he may even take on the responsibility.

SNL’s comedy bit entirely ignored older adults, who may be frail themselves, caring for spouses. Imagine a 90-pound woman trying to help her 200-pound husband get to the bathroom. But there isn’t much funny about that.

In reality, caring for an aging relative is brutal on family dynamics. Some families pull together and make it a team sport. Others blow up. More than a few older adults refuse help of any kind. Point is: This is way more complicated than SNL pretends. That’s not surprising. You can’t reduce this complex, often painful, activity to a three minute TV comedy bit.

Closing The Caregiving Gaps

After we all get a good laugh at the slacker sons, here are ways we could help family caregivers, no matter their gender:

  • There is support out there, but it often is hard to find. Effective and visible assistance navigating our fragmented maze of available programs would be an easy, cost-effective start. This help exists, both from government, non-profits, and for-profit businesses. But it often is invisible. And there needs to be much more of it.
  • A second step would be to give family caregivers what they often say they want most: Money to support themselves and purchase the most appropriate services for their loved ones. That could come from a public insurance program, a redesigned Medicare program, and for some, from Medicaid. But wherever it comes from, the care system needs more funding.
  • Medical and long-term care need to be better integrated. Without help, family members never will succeed in coordinating primary care, specialty care, medication management, and personal supports. It is not too much to ask all these providers to talk to one another. Actually, today, it is.
  • The health care system must do a better job helping family caregivers maintain their own good health. That includes emotional support which, by the way, is more difficult for men than women. When those caregivers break, as many do, so does the entire support system for their loved ones. Some groups are providing that help. Faith communities may do it. Community-based organizations can help. I’m on the board of a non-profit called org that provides online support to, yes, caregiving daughters.
  • The US needs more direct care workers to supplement family members. That will take changes in immigration law and better pay and working conditions.
  • Support for middle-income families is important. The Older Americans Act provides some modest programs, such as Meals on Wheels, adult day, and transportation. But they are underfunded and remain in legislative limbo.

Credit SNL for highlighting family caregiving. But comedy is at its best when it unveils truth. And this bit illustrated only a fragment of the real story of caregiving. The rest: Family caregivers, whatever their gender, need help. And that’s no joke.