Fresh off their overwhelming election victory, congressional Democrats are eying a broad range of health and long-term care initiatives. But they have yet to tackle what may be their most vexing challenge: How they’d pay what would be a very hefty price tag.
They could fund each of their priorities individually—an income tax increase for this, a payroll tax hike for that. Or they could treat these reforms as a single, holistic package and pay for them together.
They can’t do it with the income tax, which may be reaching its capacity to fund government. They may not be able to do it by raising payroll taxes, which already support Social Security and Medicare hospital insurance.
A Health Care VAT
But what about a Value-Added Tax, which they could label a health care tax? A VAT taxes consumption rather than income and almost every major developed country has one.
A well-designed VAT is relatively easy to administer since it is collected by businesses at every stage of production.
A pure VAT is regressive, since low- and moderate-income people spend more of their income than high-income households. But that problem can be fixed with a large exemption. See this plan by tax law professor Michael Graetz.
The idea of a health VAT hardly is new. My former Tax Policy Center colleague Len Burman proposed such a tax back in 2009 and updated it in 2014. A dedicated health care VAT would have at least four big benefits.
Big Benefits
First, it could fully fund many big new government-run health and long-term care programs. With the feds running a $2 trillion annual deficit and a $32 trillion public debt, spending trillions more on care would be unsustainable and, probably, politically unrealistic.
Second, it could build public support for controlling health and long-term care costs by making these expenses transparent. Government would be motivated to use dollars most efficiently because, if it did not, the tax would rise, and so would voter anger.
Today, most health and long-term care costs are paid through the government general fund (with borrowed money). We never really see the full consequences of those high-priced drugs or needless tests.
A dedicated health tax could encourage policymakers to enact well-designed reforms to keep costs—and VAT rates—in check, even if it meant stepping on the toes of special interests.
Third, Americans seem to like the idea of dedicated taxes. Paying a VAT that explicitly funds medical and long-term care may be more attractive than raising an income tax that could be used for almost any government service.
A VAT could significantly lower income taxes, which no longer would have to fund Medicaid, large chunks of Medicare, and many other federal health programs. And it should reduce health insurance premiums.
Such a tax also has an important societal benefit. Unlike, say, a wealth tax, everybody would pay a VAT (though many low-income people would get a rebate to offset much of the levy). That gives everyone ownership of the nation’s care system. And it would be much more stable than a program funded only by the well-connected few, who will try to get it repealed at the first opportunity.
Congress could go even further by pairing a VAT with substantial income tax reform. By scrubbing that levy of many of its special interest tax breaks and adding a VAT, Congress could make the tax laws more fair and more efficient, while reducing income tax rates.
Funding A Long Wish List
And a VAT could fund many Democratic goals. They want to repeal some of the Medicaid cuts Congress and the Trump Administration won in 2025, restore the Biden-era Affordable Care Act insurance subsidies, and expand some Medicare benefits to include, for example, vision and dental care.
For long-term care, their wish list may include more funding for Medicaid home and community-based services, more support for family caregivers, and better pay for direct care workers.
In the longer run, Democrats are looking at some version of Medicare for All, though they disagree on what that means. Some also would like to create a Medicare long-term care benefit or a public long-term care insurance system.
Public long-term care insurance could—and should—pay for itself through some sort of dedicated universal premium/tax. But all these other ideas would cost a lot of money.
The Math
Here is some dreaded math:
A broad-based 5% VAT could generate about $3.4 trillion over the next decade, according to the Congressional Budget Office.
Repealing the deduction for employer-sponsored health insurance, which would be largely unnecessary with a big public health insurance program, could raise another $3 trillion over 10 years, according to the Tax Policy Center.
It won’t pay for full-blown Medicare for All. In 2018, my Urban Institute colleagues estimated that replacing all private insurance with a federal program (and adding a long-term care benefit) would cost more than $30 trillion over 10 years. The price today would be significantly higher, given health care cost increases.
Still, $6 trillion buys a lot. A generous Medicare home and community-based long-term care program could cost about $1 trillion over 10 years, though some would be offset with Medicaid savings. Expanding Medicaid LTSS could run $400 billion.
Adding a dental benefit to Medicare might cost up to $400 billion over a decade. A vision benefit: about $30 billion.
A so-called public option health reform, a sort-of middle ground between today’s system and a full public program, would cost government several hundred billion dollars, depending on benefit design and how much is collected in premiums.
A VAT plus income tax reform could pay for it all.
What Will Congress Do?
Will Congress pass such a tax? Probably not. Tackling both health reform and tax reform at the same time probably would be too much of a heavy lift for risk-averse lawmakers.
And it won’t happen without strong White House leadership. The Trump Administration isn’t interested. Will the next president be bolder?
Lawmakers likely will prefer a long list of nickel-and-dime tax increases and the ever-popular more borrowing. While some Democrats and Republicans have backed consumption taxes in the past, next year’s Democrats are more likely to look to high-income households and corporations rather than a broad-based tax for any new revenue.
And they’d miss a generational opportunity.
Leave A Comment