Before policymakers try to fix the US’s long-term care disorder, they must resolve one fundamental question: Which government program should serve as the chassis for any public long-term care system?
Lawmakers have three choices: Retain Medicaid, shift the primary responsibility for long-term care to Medicare, or create a public insurance program. While all could play some role in a new system, one must serve as the basic structure. The other two could fill any gaps.
Here’s a brief look at the pros and cons of each.
Medicaid.
It’s the foundation of government long-term services and supports today. While it is run by the states under broad federal rules, the feds now pay about 70% of its costs. Older adults and younger people with disabilities are eligible if they need significant support, have very little income and, in most states, few financial resources besides a family home.
Most care is provided by insurance companies. And there is much variation among state programs. Some mostly provide home and community-based care while others still focus on nursing homes, the only site where Medicaid pays for room and board as well as care.
PROS:
- Medicaid’s main benefit is its familiarity. Because it already is the foundation of the existing public system, it may be easier to fix than creating an entirely new program.
- Providers have built their business models around Medicaid and its many rules. And many advocates are locked into the system as well. Enhancing Medicaid’s long-term care benefit would be less disruptive, though perhaps disruption would be good.
- It focuses resources on those with the greatest financial need.
CONS:
- Medicaid benefits many younger people with disabilities but only a small slice of older adults, most of whom receive unpaid care by their families at home.
- It is heavily rules-based and extremely complex to navigate. This both encourages fraud and prevents many eligible people from receiving benefits, simply because they can’t manage the system.
- These rules severely limit how dollars can be spent, making it difficult to tailor care to individual needs.
- It is politically unstable, as we learned in 2025 when the Trump Administration and congressional Republicans slashed the program by $1 trillion over the next decade. Because it is seen as a welfare program only for the poor and is extremely expensive at a time of historic budget deficits and debt, it inevitably will be a target for cuts.
Medicare
Today, Medicare covers health care for 70 million people but, with a few narrow exceptions, provides no long-term services and supports. General government, rather than premiums, pays for about 70% of Medicare Part B care and Part D drug insurance. Payroll taxes finance some of Part A hospital insurance.
PROS:
- Merging long-term care and medical treatment into a single system could make it easier to integrate both forms of care.
- It could especially simplify life for many of those eligible both for Medicaid and Medicare since they’d get medical treatment and personal care through the same system.
- Medicare covers a much larger population than Medicaid. Folding another benefit into the program would have much greater reach than Medicaid.
- Unlike Medicaid, Medicare is enormously popular and better protected from future cuts.
- The biggest advantage may be due to a common misunderstanding. Most Americans think Medicare already provides long-term care benefits. Policymakers could follow the public perception and make it so.
CONS:
- Like Medicaid, Medicare is heavily rules-based. It will pay for certain benefits or providers but not others, even when they can help a patient. For example, Medicare will pay only for approved home health agencies. In rural communities, there may be none.
- Most LTSS proposals focus on original Medicare but what will happen to the roughly half of all Medicare beneficiaries now enrolled in Medicare Advantage managed care? Designing a system that works for both original Medicare and MA will be difficult.
- Medicare providers, such as hospitals and doctors, have little experience and often less interest in social supports and personal care. Improving financial incentives for coordinated care will help change their focus but it also will require a fundamental change in health care culture. And that could take years.
- Nearly all Medicare LTSS proposals would limit benefits to those receiving care at home or in the community. But that means many people would lose their Medicare LTSS benefit just when they need to enter a facility, where care often is most expensive.
- How would Medicare LTSS be funded? One recent, highly-targeted proposal could pay for itself. But a more generous Medicare benefit, say 20 hours weekly of home care, could cost up to $100 billion-a-year. It likely would have to be funded with some form of tax increase, which could be a hard sell at first.
- Hill Democrats already are pushing to expand Medicare’s health benefits, which inevitably will increase those government costs. Adding an expensive long-term care benefit will be a challenge.
- On the other hand, once such a program took effect, it would be extremely difficult to reduce benefits if it becomes more costly than expected. That would require even a bigger tax, premium, or more federal borrowing.
Public long-term care insurance
PROS:
- Unlike Medicare and Medicaid, an insurance benefit could be extremely flexible, especially if it is available in cash. It would help care recipients and their families fund the most appropriate care.
- As a broad-based benefit, it would be more politically stable than Medicaid.
- It would fund at least some care in a home or a facility.
- An income-based model could focus benefits on low- and middle-income people, who need it most. Those who require care but never worked still would be eligible for Medicaid.
- A catastrophic version could reduce Medicaid LTSS costs by as much as one-third.
- It could be fully funded, without adding to the federal budget deficit, with a dedicated tax or premium. Because workers would begin paying at a young age, the cost could be quite low, less than 1% of payroll in some models. At least in theory, that would allow the program to build up a reserve fund to pay benefits over time.
- The premium/tax could be tied to the program cost. If it becomes more costly than expected, payments would rise. This could help control costs.
- Because the benefit would be limited, it might encourage people to save or buy insurance to help fill the gap.
CONS
- As an entirely new federal program, it would require a huge amount of complex design work.
- It must be funded with a mandatory contribution, or tax. This would be very controversial.
- Because it would be separate from Medicare’s health benefits, it would not help integrate medical and personal care.
Each of these ideas has its own advantages and disadvantages, though I much prefer Medicare or insurance to Medicaid. But almost anything lawmakers do would be an improvement over today’s mess.
Leave A Comment