Want to see the future of adult day programs for the frail elderly and adults with disabilities? Just watch what is happening in California, where 26,000 participants and the centers that care for them are struggling to manage state budget cuts and huge uncertainty.
Adult day programs can be a key support for the frail elderly or other adults with disabilities who are trying to live at home. They provide much-needed meals, exercise, companionship, and often an early warning system for health problems. They can also provide critical respite for family caregivers. They may, although the evidence is not clear, make it possible for people to stay at home and, at the same time, avoid unneeded hospitalizations.
But adult day is often funded by state Medicaid programs. And Medicaid, which is under severe financial stress, is looking to squeeze dollars from its burgeoning budgets. As I wrote last year, California, whose budget problems are worse than most, tried to end its support of adult day for 35,000 seniors and other adults with disabilities in nearly 300 centers. Had the cuts taken effect, most of those centers would have closed. Last year, California spent about $169 million on adult day through its Medicaid program (called Medi-Cal).
In response, advocacy groups sued and the state settled. It agreed to continue to provide care for 9,000 of those who most need assistance. Each of the remaining 26,000 participants must now each be evaluated to determine if they meet tight new rules for eligibility. Nice story on this assessment process on Kaiser Health News today.
California officials believe that about half will be declared ineligible for financial support. They say they can save $28 million this year and $92 million next year.
It is not clear what the assessments and the inevitable appeals will cost, but it won’t be cheap. And the Kaiser story suggests that most participants will eventually be found eligible even under the new criteria so it isn’t clear how much money the state will save, even in the short run.
In the longer term, it is likely that at least some of those who are kicked out of the adult day programs will no longer be able to live at home, and may end up in nursing homes–at far greater cost to California. Nursing home care costs on average three times as much as an adult day program. But in today’s budget environment, few elected officials are thinking about the long run.
The uncertainty has already taken a toll. The Los Angeles Times reports that 20 adult day programs closed last year in anticipation of the budget cuts and others remain in limbo. While some participants pay privately, most receive government assistance. Many centers are run by non-profits that face their own budget challenges.
Sadly, I suspect this story will be repeated elsewhere in the country.
A senior citizen from California came to live with her daughter and I got to know her through church. She used to complain about our daycares in Texas because our state only offers a place to go and eat. It doesn’t offer any healthcare, therapies or mental health care. She used to say that California offered so much and people didn’t have to leave for the treatments they needed.
Interesting about what California is doing to people now.
What an important article to bring to light the jeopardy adult day care faces today. As you noted, for many families, day care is the difference between people remaining at home and going into snfs at far greater cost to our government. We want our folks to remain at home, even if we have to juggle children, work, domestic chores and pick ups and drop offs. It’s better for our parents, better for the families and a good use of government dollars. How do we make this known to Sacramento and Washington?
And how may I help?
[…]The Battle over California’s Adult Day Programs « Caring for Our Parents[…]…